The Secret in Their Eyes (2009) – 4K UHD / Blu-ray Limited Edition Review
My Bloody Reviews Verdict 7

The Secret in Their Eyes (2009) – 4K UHD / Blu-ray Limited Edition Review A retired criminal investigator revisits a decades-old murder case while attempting to write a novel based on the crime. As he retraces the original investigation and revisits long-buried evidence, unresolved feelings begin to surface, particularly when he reconnects with a former ..

Summary Rating: 7.0 from 10 7.0 good

The Secret in Their Eyes (2009) – 4K UHD / Blu-ray Limited Edition Review

The Secret in Their Eyes (2009) – 4K UHD / Blu-ray Limited Edition Review

A retired criminal investigator revisits a decades-old murder case while attempting to write a novel based on the crime. As he retraces the original investigation and revisits long-buried evidence, unresolved feelings begin to surface, particularly when he reconnects with a former colleague with whom he shared a complicated history.

Winner of the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film, Juan José Campanella’s The Secret in Their Eyes arrives with an impressive collection of awards and glowing reviews behind it. Described on its original release as both ‘harrowing’ and a film that ‘will stay with you’, I approached this Argentine crime drama with fairly high expectations. Perhaps a little too high, as while it’s undoubtedly well made, thoroughly watchable and occasionally impressive, I found it likeable rather than particularly remarkable. A perfectly respectable film, certainly, but one that never quite delivered the emotional knockout I’d been led to expect.

Ricardo Darín is excellent as Benjamín Espósito, the retired investigator for Argentina’s criminal courts, anchoring the film with a wonderfully understated performance. He’s ably supported by an ensemble cast who rarely put a foot wrong, although Guillermo Francella arguably steals the show as Pablo Sandoval, Espósito’s alcoholic friend and former assistant. His character provides some much-needed humour and personality amid the increasingly sombre proceedings.

Based on Eduardo Sacheri’s 2005 novel La pregunta de sus ojos (The Question in Their Eyes), which he adapted for the screen alongside Campanella, the film moves between the present day and the mid-Seventies, gradually connecting its central murder investigation with Argentina’s turbulent political history. It’s a relatively straightforward crime thriller at heart, but one elevated by assured direction, strong performances and a carefully constructed narrative that explores obsession, justice, guilt and the passage of time.

The film’s two timelines also provide an interesting technical challenge, although the ageing make-up doesn’t always fare particularly well under the scrutiny of this exceptionally polished 4K presentation. That’s a minor complaint, however, when the overall quality of this Second Sight release is taken into consideration. The picture is immaculate, the sound equally impressive, and I found myself hooked from the opening scenes, occasionally more engrossed by the sheer quality of the presentation than by what was unfolding on screen.

One sequence in particular deserves special mention: the extraordinary five-minute tracking shot that sweeps through a packed football stadium during a live match. An astonishing technical achievement, the sequence involved three days of filming, following three months of pre-production and an incredible nine months of post-production. Around 200 extras were involved, with visual effects used to transform the stadium into a convincing spectacle accommodating almost 50,000 spectators. It’s a breathtaking piece of filmmaking and easily one of the film’s most memorable moments.

The film went on to gross more than $34 million worldwide, becoming one of Argentina’s most successful productions, and made history by securing the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film at the 82nd Oscars. It was only the second Argentine film to receive the honour, following The Official Story (1985), making Argentina the first South American country to win the award twice.

There was also an American remake in 2015, boasting a heavyweight cast that included Julia Roberts, Nicole Kidman, Chiwetel Ejiofor and Alfred Molina. Despite such impressive credentials, it failed to make much of an impression on either critics or audiences, further demonstrating that some stories are best left in their original form.

Ultimately, The Secret in Their Eyes is a well-acted, intelligently constructed crime drama with some genuinely impressive filmmaking behind it. While I wouldn’t quite place it among the genre’s greats, there’s plenty to admire, and Second Sight’s outstanding 4K presentation makes this a particularly attractive release. A good film, then, even if it didn’t quite leave the lasting impression its reputation had led me to anticipate.

Special Features

Audio commentary by Gizella Meneses and Dave Park
Audio commentary with Director Juan José Campanella
A Blessed Movie: a new interview with Juan José Campanella
The Collaborators: a new interview with Producers Mariela Besuievsky and Gerardo Herrero
A Gift: a new interview with Composers Emilio Kauderer and Federico Jusid
Decoding the Mystery: Joe Lipsett on The Secret in Their Eyes
‘Making Of’
Limited Edition Content

Rigid slipcase with new artwork by The OC Agency
120-page book with new essays by Rob Hunter, Tom Phelan, Andrew Pope, Shelagh Rowan-Legg, Gabriel Eljaiek Rodriguez and Nadine Whitney
6 collectors’ art cards

logo